Case: FTT had unable to determine legitimate expectation issue
The FTT held it lacked jurisdiction to decide the legitimate expectation claim, but found HMRC was not acting unfairly in recovering VAT on carpets supplies
In Abbey Group Ltd TC 10048, the First-tier Tribunal dismissed an appeal against HMRC assessments recovering input VAT on carpets supplied free to buyers of new homes.
Carpets are not ordinarily installed in a new building, so the VAT incurred on them is blocked input tax. Abbey had recovered the VAT, and HMRC issued assessments under section 73(2) VATA 1994. Abbey accepted the VAT treatment going forward but argued that a 2016 HMRC conversation gave it a legitimate expectation that it could retain the historic recovery.
The Tribunal first considered whether it had jurisdiction to decide a legitimate expectation challenge as part of a VAT assessment appeal. It held that it did not. Although section 73(2) involves a discretion subject to public law constraints, section 83(1)(p) is concerned with whether an assessment is within HMRC’s statutory power and its amount not with broader judicial review style challenges. The Tribunal considered that Parliament reserved legitimate expectation claims for the High Court.
Even if it had jurisdiction, the Tribunal rejected the claim on its merits. HMRC had given a clear assurance and Abbey had disclosed the facts. However, Abbey had not changed its commercial arrangements in reliance on that assurance; it continued supplying carpets because of its business model. Preventing HMRC from assessing would allow Abbey to retain VAT it was not entitled to recover, giving it an advantage over similar taxpayers. The balance of fairness favoured HMRC, and the appeal was dismissed.
Sources
General information on a VAT development, not advice on your situation. Speak to a VAT specialist before acting on it.