The courts decide it on commercial reality, not labels: Mainpay found a supply of staff, Isle of Wight found a supply of care. Sitting alongside that general test are two special rules, the locum doctor exemption in Item 5 and the Nursing Agencies Concession, and a group of roles that fall outside both. This guide maps all of it, and shows why the 1 May 2027 change makes the line matter more, not less.
This is one of three connected guides on locum doctors and VAT. Before you can work out what the 1 May 2027 change does, or whether you can reclaim VAT charged in error, you need the test underneath it all: care, or a supply of staff? This guide sets out that test, how it applies across doctors, nurses and the roles that fall outside, and what the paperwork has to show. The companion guides cover the change itself, and the refund claims.
This is one of three connected guides
This guide is about the care vs staff test that decides the VAT in the first place. Its companions cover the change coming on 1 May 2027, and how to reclaim VAT that was charged in error on locum doctors.
- Locum doctors and VAT: what changes on 1 May 2027
- Can you reclaim the VAT wrongly charged on locum doctors?
- Medical staff and VAT: care, or a supply of staff? (you're reading this)
Common mistakes & confusionsWhere the care vs staff line catches people out
- Thinking a clinical worker is automatically exempt. Exemption follows the supply of care, not the person's qualification. A fully registered doctor supplied as staff is a standard-rated supply.
- Relying on the job title in the contract. The test is the commercial reality of what is supplied, not what the contract calls it. A contract that says "supply of care" does not make it care if, in practice, you are just providing a worker.
- Treating all nurses like doctors. Nurses sit under a separate rule, the Nursing Agencies Concession, with its own conditions. The locum doctor exemption in Item 5 does not cover them.
- Assuming every medical role is covered. Physician associates and anaesthesia associates are not within the locum doctor exemption, so supplies of them as staff are standard-rated.
- Forgetting who holds responsibility for the care. The question of who is clinically and contractually responsible for delivering the care to the patient usually decides which side of the line you are on.
- Ignoring the 1 May 2027 change. From that date the locum doctor exemption goes, so the general care vs staff test becomes the main thing standing between a supply and 20% VAT.
The question under all of it: care, or staff?
UK VAT treats two things very differently. A supply of medical care, treatment that protects, maintains or restores a person's health, provided by an appropriate health professional, is exempt under Item 1 of Group 7 of Schedule 9. A supply of staff, where you provide the worker and someone else directs and is responsible for the care, is a standard-rated supply of services at 20%.
That distinction is the whole game for anyone supplying medical people. The same qualified doctor or nurse can be an exempt supply of care in one arrangement and a standard-rated supply of staff in another. So the question is never just "is this person a clinician?" It is "what am I actually supplying, the care, or the person who provides it?"
The test the courts and HMRC apply
Because labels do not decide it, the courts look at the commercial and economic reality of the arrangement. Two linked questions do most of the work: who is responsible for delivering the care to the patient, and who directs and controls the worker while they do it? Where the supplier carries that responsibility and control, the supply looks like care. Where the client does, it looks like a supply of staff.
This is the line the Court of Appeal drew in Mainpay, where the arrangement was found to be a standard-rated supply of staff, and the one the First-tier Tribunal applied the other way in Isle of Wight, where the supply was found to be exempt care. HMRC's own position tracks the same idea: medical care stays exempt, but a supply of staff does not, and the difference is who is responsible for the care and who controls the worker.
In the second, the agency simply places the same consultant into a hospital's own theatre list, where the hospital directs the work and carries clinical responsibility. Now the agency is supplying a worker, not care, so the supply is standard-rated at 20%. Same person, same skills, two different VAT answers, driven entirely by who is responsible and who is in control.
Locum doctors: a special exemption, for now
Alongside the general care test sits a specific rule for doctors. Item 5 of Group 7 exempts the provision of a deputy for a registered medical practitioner, the "locum doctor" exemption, where the doctor is on the register kept under the Medical Act 1983. This is why supplies of GMC-registered locum doctors have been treated as exempt even in arrangements that might otherwise have looked like a supply of staff.
That special rule is temporary. It is being repealed from 1 May 2027, after which locum doctors fall back on the general care vs staff test like everyone else. The companion guide on the change covers exactly what that means and what to do before the date.
Nurses and care workers: the Nursing Agencies Concession
Nurses do not rely on Item 5. Instead, HMRC operates the Nursing Agencies Concession, set out in Notice 701/57, which lets agencies treat the supply of registered nurses, and of unregistered nursing auxiliaries and care assistants working under appropriate supervision, as exempt where they are supplied to provide nursing care to patients.
The concession has conditions, and they matter. It applies where the staff are engaged in providing care to the final consumer, not where the agency is simply supplying labour up a chain for someone else to deploy. Get the structure wrong, for example inserting an umbrella layer that breaks the link to patient care, and the concession can fall away, leaving a standard-rated supply.
Who is not covered: physician associates, anaesthesia associates and others
Not every clinical role sits inside these rules. Physician associates and anaesthesia associates, although now regulated, are not registered medical practitioners for the purposes of Item 5, so the locum doctor exemption does not reach them. A supply of a physician associate as staff is therefore standard-rated unless it genuinely amounts to an exempt supply of care under the general test.
The same caution applies to many allied health roles and to administrative or non-clinical staff supplied into healthcare settings. Being supplied to a hospital does not make a supply exempt. The role has to fit a specific exemption, or the arrangement has to be a genuine supply of care, for anything other than 20% to apply.
Telling care from staff in practice
When you are trying to place a real arrangement on the right side of the line, a few markers do most of the work. Who holds the responsibility for the care delivered to the patient? Who directs and supervises the clinical work day to day? Does the supplier carry the clinical risk, or just send a person? And, crucially, does the paperwork match what actually happens, or does it describe a supply of care while the reality is a supply of labour?
That last point is where disputes are won and lost. HMRC and the tribunals look through the contract to the economic reality, so a mismatch between the wording and the operation is a weakness, not a shield. The time to align the two is before HMRC asks, not after.
A VAT Expert Call gives you a Senior specialist's read on whether your medical staffing supplies are care or a supply of staff, and what that means for your pricing.
What the 1 May 2027 change does to this map
The repeal of the locum doctor exemption does not change the general test, but it removes one of the special shortcuts. After 1 May 2027, a locum doctor supplied as staff is standard-rated, and only a genuine supply of care stays exempt. In other words, the care vs staff line stops being a second-best argument for doctors and becomes the main event.
That is why this test is worth understanding now. The arrangements that will keep their exemption after the change are the ones that are genuinely supplies of care, with the responsibility and control to match, and the paperwork to prove it. The companion guide on the change sets out the timeline and the practical steps; this one gives you the test those steps turn on.
When you might need expert VAT advisory
The care vs staff line looks simple and is anything but, because it turns on the reality of each arrangement rather than a rule you can look up. In practice, these are the situations where a senior specialist's read changes the outcome:
- You supply medical or nursing staff and are not sure whether your supplies are exempt care or standard-rated staff
- You rely on the Nursing Agencies Concession and want to be sure your structure still qualifies
- You supply physician associates, anaesthesia associates or allied health staff and need to know where they stand
- You are restructuring contracts so that supplies are, and read as, genuine supplies of care
- You are preparing for the 1 May 2027 change and want your doctor supplies reviewed before the date
- You are an accountant with a healthcare or staffing client and want a second opinion on the classification
Whether you're a staffing business or an accountant acting for one, we focus on the VAT questions where extra expertise pays off, and we work in plain English.