Two things cut the amount down: unjust enrichment, if you passed the VAT on to a customer who bore it, and partial exemption, because input tax you recovered on those supplies has to be netted off. Only the business that made the supply and charged the VAT can claim. This guide is about getting that claim right; its companions cover the 1 May 2027 change and the care vs staff test.
This is one of three connected guides on locum doctors and VAT. For a few years, supplies that the courts have since found to be exempt were widely treated as standard-rated, and a lot of VAT was charged that may not have been due. This guide is about claiming it back: who can, how, how far, and what reduces it. The companion guides cover the change coming on 1 May 2027, and the care vs staff test underneath it all.
This is one of three connected guides
This guide is about reclaiming VAT charged in error on locum doctors. Its companions cover the change coming on 1 May 2027, and the care vs staff test that decides the VAT in the first place.
- Locum doctors and VAT: what changes on 1 May 2027
- Can you reclaim the VAT wrongly charged on locum doctors? (you're reading this)
- Medical staff and VAT: care, or a supply of staff?
Common mistakes & confusionsWhere locum doctor VAT claims trip suppliers up
- Assuming the buyer claims it back. Only the business that made the supply and charged the output VAT can reclaim it from HMRC. A trust or practice that was charged the VAT does not make this claim, the supplier does.
- Letting the four-year clock run down. Claims reach back four years, and every month that passes drops the oldest month off the end. The 1 May 2027 repeal does not extend this, so delay costs you the earliest periods.
- Ignoring unjust enrichment. If you charged the VAT and your customer bore the cost, HMRC can refuse to pay you the refund unless you pass it back to them. The money cannot simply stay with you.
- Forgetting to net off input tax. If the supplies were exempt, the input tax you recovered on their costs was not due. A claim for over-declared output tax has to be reduced by that recovered input tax first.
- Claiming for the wrong staff. The exemption, and so the claim, applies only to GMC-registered locum doctors. VAT charged on physician associates, anaesthesia associates or allied health professionals is not within it.
- Treating it as automatic. HMRC reviews each claim, and will not pay where there is ongoing litigation or where it would leave you better off than you should be. A claim needs to be built, not just submitted.
Why you may have charged VAT you did not need to
For years, a locum doctor supplied through an agency was widely treated as a standard-rated supply of staff rather than exempt medical care, a view supported by the Court of Appeal in Mainpay. On that basis, agencies and umbrella companies charged 20% on these supplies as a matter of course.
That changed in 2025, when the First-tier Tribunal in Isle of Wight NHS Foundation Trust found that supplies of GMC-registered locum doctors were exempt, and HMRC accepted the point in 2026. The consequence is that a lot of VAT charged in the earlier period may never have been due. Where it was not, the business that charged it can look to recover it.
Who can claim, and what for
The claim belongs to the supplier. HMRC is clear that only the person who made the supply and charged the output tax can reclaim it, so it is the agency, umbrella or other supplier, not the NHS trust or practice that paid the invoice, who makes the claim. The claim is for output tax charged at the standard rate on supplies that should have been exempt.
The scope is narrow and specific: it covers supplies of GMC-registered locum doctors, the supplies HMRC accepted were exempt. It does not extend to other medical staff, and it does not turn every crypto-style assumption on its head: you are claiming only where the supply genuinely fell within the exemption. Working out which of your past supplies qualify is the first, and often the hardest, part of the exercise.
The four-year window, and why it keeps shrinking
Claims for over-declared VAT are subject to a four-year cap. You can go back four years from the date of the claim, no further, so the window is always moving: every month that passes, the earliest month you could have claimed drops away. On a large volume of locum supplies, those early months can be worth a lot.
The repeal coming on 1 May 2027 does not help here. It is forward-looking, and HMRC has confirmed that it does not affect refund claims for the period while the exemption is in force. So the practical message is simple: the sooner a claim is prepared, the more of the four years it captures, and the less is lost to the calendar.
How to make the claim
The mechanism depends on size. Smaller errors can be corrected by adjusting your next VAT return; larger ones are notified to HMRC on form VAT652, the error-correction notification. For these locum doctor claims, HMRC has set up a dedicated route: the VAT652 is sent to a specific HMRC mailbox with the reference for the relevant brief in the subject line, and HMRC then reviews the claim on its facts rather than paying it automatically.
That review looks at whether the supplies really were exempt, whether the output tax was correctly accounted for across the supply chain, and whether paying the claim would leave you better off than you should be. In other words, a credible claim is one that is evidenced and quantified properly before it is submitted, not a round-number estimate.
Its claim is not simply £600,000. The input tax it recovered on the costs of those supplies, say £90,000, has to be netted off, because exempt supplies do not carry recovery. And if it passed the VAT on to clients who bore the cost, HMRC will look at unjust enrichment before paying. The real figure is the one left after those adjustments, which is exactly why these claims are worth building carefully.
What reduces your claim: unjust enrichment and partial exemption
Two adjustments stand between the headline figure and the cash. The first is unjust enrichment. If you charged the VAT and your customer actually bore it, refunding the VAT to you alone would leave you better off at your customer's expense. HMRC can refuse the claim on that basis unless you undertake to reimburse the customers who carried the cost, under its reimbursement arrangements.
The second is partial exemption. If the supplies were exempt, then the VAT you recovered on the costs behind them was not recoverable after all. So a claim for the over-declared output tax has to be reduced by the input tax you clawed back on those supplies. Both adjustments are normal, both are expected by HMRC, and both have to be worked through before the claim is a real number.
HMRC Response Support builds and submits your locum doctor refund claim, quantified, evidenced and adjusted for unjust enrichment and partial exemption.
When HMRC will not pay, yet
A valid claim is not always a claim that gets paid straight away. HMRC has said it will not process claims where there is ongoing litigation on the point, or where it needs to carry out assurance activity first, and it will not pay a claim that would result in your unjust enrichment. None of that means the claim is lost, but it does mean timing and presentation matter.
The practical consequence is that a claim submitted with the right evidence, the adjustments already made, and the exempt analysis clearly set out, moves faster and further than one that leaves HMRC to do the work. For a large claim, getting that right the first time is usually the difference between a clean repayment and a drawn-out query.
The other half: the change coming on 1 May 2027
This claim looks backwards, at the period while the exemption applies. Looking forwards, that exemption is being repealed from 1 May 2027, after which supplies of staff become standard-rated and only genuine supplies of care stay exempt. The two are connected: the same care vs staff analysis that supports your claim for the past also decides your VAT from 2027.
So if you are looking at a refund claim, it is worth dealing with both directions at once, the money you can recover for the exempt period, and the pricing and contracts you need to fix before the change. Our companion guides cover each in turn.
When you might need expert VAT advisory
A locum doctor refund claim is real money, but it is a technical claim with a shrinking window and several ways to get it wrong. In practice, the situations below are where a senior specialist's read meaningfully improves the outcome:
- You charged VAT on locum doctor supplies and want to know whether, and how much, you can reclaim
- You need the qualifying supplies identified and the claim quantified across four years
- You need the unjust enrichment and partial exemption adjustments worked out properly before you submit
- You want the claim built, evidenced and presented so HMRC pays it rather than queries it
- You were charged the VAT as a buyer and want to understand your position in the chain
- You are an accountant with a healthcare or staffing client and want the claim reviewed before it goes in
Whether you're a staffing business with a claim to make or an accountant acting for one, we focus on the VAT questions where extra expertise pays off, and we work in plain English.