VAT News

Case: No VAT invoice no input tax, FTT upholds HMRC refusal for watch exporter

The FTT found that till receipts and bank statements could not replace valid VAT invoices, and HMRC was entitled to refuse alternative evidence of input tax.

In Unatrade Ltd TC 10053, the First-Tier Tribunal dismissed an appeal against HMRC’s refusal to allow input VAT recovery in the absence of valid VAT invoices.

Unatrade bought luxury goods, mainly Rolex watches, from UK retailers and exported them to Hong Kong for onward sale in China. Its sales were zero-rated, so it submitted monthly VAT returns and recovered the VAT on purchases. During a compliance check, HMRC requested documents for all transactions in one VAT period. Unatrade provided till receipts, bank statements and sales/export records, but no VAT invoices.

HMRC disallowed 90% of the input tax claimed, having verified that Unatrade’s purchasing model was consistent across other periods. The decision was upheld on review. Unatrade argued that it could not force retailers to issue VAT invoices and that denying recovery solely for missing invoices breached VAT neutrality.

The Tribunal’s role was supervisory: it could assess only whether HMRC’s decision was reasonable. It found that Unatrade had substantially failed to evidence the VAT charged. Although VAT could be calculated from the receipts, that was merely an assumption; it did not prove that VAT had actually been charged or paid.

The Tribunal applied Tower Bridge GP Ltd, confirming that HMRC’s discretion to accept alternative evidence is an exception to the general requirement for a valid VAT invoice. It is not a substitute for that requirement. Unatrade had not shown it had asked suppliers for invoices, and its alternative documents lacked the necessary VAT detail. HMRC was therefore entitled to deny the input tax claims, and the appeal was dismissed.

Sources

General information on a VAT development, not advice on your situation. Speak to a VAT specialist before acting on it.