Case: Supercar experiences fail VAT relief test
Upper Tribunal rules personalised driving days are not rights of admission, so the temporary reduced VAT rate does not apply.
Ingliston offered supercar driving experiences and applied a temporary reduced VAT rate, available to certain tourism and leisure businesses during and shortly after the Covid-19 pandemic. The rate was 5% from July 2020 to September 2021, then 12.5% until March 2022.
The rule covered admission to attractions such as theatres, fairs, amusement parks, museums, zoos and “similar cultural events and facilities.” HMRC argued that Ingliston’s driving experiences did not qualify because customers were not simply buying entry to an attraction, they were buying a personalised driving experience.
The Upper Tribunal agreed with HMRC. It decided that a “right of admission” generally involves customers collectively enjoying the same event or facility. Although several customers were at Ingliston at the same time, each had bought a different experience for example, choosing a particular car, deciding whether to drive or be driven, and selecting a venue. That made the experience individual rather than collective.
As a result, the Tribunal found that Ingliston was selling recreational driving experiences, not admission to a cultural or leisure attraction. The reduced VAT rate therefore did not apply.
However, the Tribunal did reject HMRC’s wider argument that the driving track could not be a “similar facility” to the attractions listed in the legislation. It held that the listed attractions should be treated as examples of a broader category, rather than a strict list that had to be matched one by one.
In practical terms, the case is a reminder that VAT reliefs can depend heavily on what a customer is actually buying not simply on the type of venue or activity involved.
Sources
General information on a VAT development, not advice on your situation. Speak to a VAT specialist before acting on it.